Current location:business >>
Calling a female colleague a 'pretty woman' at work is sex discrimination, tribunal rules
business88People have gathered around
IntroductionCalling a female colleague a 'pretty woman' at work is sex discrimination, a tribunal has ruled.Sugg ...
Calling a female colleague a 'pretty woman' at work is sex discrimination, a tribunal has ruled.
Suggesting that a women's looks might help the business is not 'flattering' and risks 'diminishing' her as it wouldn't be said to a man, an employment judge found.
The ruling came in the case of an accounts manager who sued her employers after her boss told her to attend a meeting - because a male client liked 'pretty women'.
Emma Nunn said she was left feeling 'humiliated and undermined' when Adam Crouch extended the invitation purely for her physical appearance, the employment tribunal heard.
He then 'demeaned' her further by telling her to 'calm down' when she refused, before signing off his message with 'babes', it concluded.
Miss Nunn resigned from her £60,000 a year job and is now in line to receive compensation after winning her claim of sex discrimination with the judge ruled the comments were 'reducing her value to the business' and wouldn't have been made to a male colleague.
Calling a female colleague a 'pretty woman' at work is sex discrimination, a tribunal has ruled (Stock photo)
The Leicester tribunal heard Mr Crouch took over trucking firm G. & M.J. Crouch & Son, in the city, from his father in 2015, but Miss Nunn had known him as a longstanding family friend since she was 18.
She had worked part time within the vehicle recovery services business before agreeing on a permanent role on in February 2020.
Miss Nunn told the panel their particular friendship led to a 'blurring of the nature of their working relationship'.
'Mr Crouch did not speak, consult with, or treat any another female employee like he spoke and treated me,' she said.
'The 20 year friendship came with significant consequences - I tolerated his behaviour as best I could.
READ MORE: Calling a woman 'glamorous' at work risks undermining or belittling them, tribunal rules as beauty queen lawyer loses claim that her female boss racially discriminated against her by using the termAdvertisement
'He was not speaking to me like a boss more like a husband disappointed in a wife (me).
'At one level I was a trust confidante, someone to let off steam to, to disclose inner most secrets and feelings to and next I was a normal employee.'
However, the tribunal found this dynamic of not being 'a purely professional working relationship', was actually 'encouraged' by both of them.
In April 2021, Mr Crouch - who is married - sent her a message about an upcoming meeting saying: 'oh yeah you should come as [a customer] is attending - he likes pretty women.'
When she queried this, replying 'I am not coming if just for pretty face', he told her to 'calm down' and signed off with 'ok babes xx'.
In a subsequent email to Mr Crouch complaining about her treatment, she asked: 'Is that all I get recognised for that I am attractive?'
She resigned later that month, saying she felt 'humiliated and undermined' and took the firm to the tribunal, making a series of claims of sex discrimination and harassment.
While most were dismissed, the 'pretty woman' complaint was upheld.
Employment Judge Rachel Broughton said: [We] find that the 'pretty face' comment would not have been said to a man, or an equivalent comment made about a male colleague's physical attractiveness as a reason for being invited to a work meeting.
'It should have been obvious to him that such a comment would be unwelcome.
'It was not flattering [Miss Nunn], it was reducing her value to the business in that context, and what she would contribute to the meeting.
'The Tribunal conclude that the reference to 'pretty' is sexual in nature. It is about her physical attractiveness and in this context, her physical attractiveness to the opposite sex, a customer.
'The implication is that [the customer] finds her sexually attractive and would for that reason get some pleasure at looking at her in the meeting and/or interacting with her.
'The comment was sexual in nature and was said because of her sex, that she is a woman.'
EJ Broughton concluded that by referring to her as 'babes' in his response, he had 'demeaned her further'.
'Babes' in this context was not affectionate, it was making fun of her reaction and the impact his first comment had,' she continued.
'She felt she was being diminished in terms of her importance to the business and her concerns were being dealt with flippantly, [we] conclude that in this context she was genuinely and reasonably, aggrieved at both not being invited and being told that she should come not because of her work but because the male client considered her attractive.'
The judge concluded 'pretty women' and 'babes' were used 'because of [Miss Nunn]'s sex'.
'Mr Crouch would not have dismissed her concerns in the way he did, but for her sex,' she added.
'He was flippant because of the relationship they had but he used those specific terms because of her sex.
'She was upset and felt diminished professionally by his comments and the tribunal consider that it was reasonable for her to feel that way.'
A further hearing to award compensation will take place at a later date.
Tags:
Reprint:Friends are welcome to share on the Internet, but please indicate the source of the article when reprinting it.“World Watch news portal”。http://japan.brianlynch.org/content-56e899090.html
Related articles
‘The Blue Angels,’ filmed for IMAX, puts viewers in the ‘box’ with the elite flying squad
businessIf you’re looking for a little bit of that “ Top Gun: Maverick ” spectacle and thrill at the movie t ...
【business】
Read morePeople in traditional costumes celebrate traditional Flower Festival in Fujian
businessPeople in traditional costumes celebrate Hua Zhao Jie, or the traditional Flower Festival, at the We ...
【business】
Read morePeople of Zhuang ethnic group celebrate traditional diving festival in Guizhou
businessGirls of Zhuang ethnic group holding red umbrellas attend a diving matchmaking activity on the secon ...
【business】
Read more
Popular articles
Latest articles
Sarah Jessica Parker divides opinion with enormous hat on set of And Just Like That
Water use remains steady as GDP increases
Xi Replies to Letter from Philadelphia Orchestra CEO
Craftsman brings traditional sculptures to life
Kylie Jenner displays her VERY edgy fashion sense in cleavage
Coal production in China reach historic highs last year
LINKS
- Cannes sets lineup with Lanthimos, Coppola and Trump film 'The Apprentice'
- Eating less meat would be good for the Earth. Small nudges can change behavior
- Total solar eclipse: What's the path and what to know for Monday April 8
- Eating less meat would be good for the Earth. Small nudges can change behavior
- Blind people can hear and feel April's total solar eclipse with new technology
- Odysseus moon lander sends new images in its last hours
- Four astronauts from four countries return to Earth after six months in orbit
- CBS says its daytime show 'The Talk' will end its run in December after 15 seasons
- Rookie Adama Sanogo has 22 points and 20 rebounds to shatter career highs, Bulls top Wizards 129
- A Moroccan town protests water management plans